Rappler – Why Roxas, Espina out of loop? ‘Operational safety’ – Purisima

Former PNP chief Director General Alan Purisima says he was only following the SAF’s ‘plan’ when he ‘advised’ that top officials be kept in the dark till the last minute on the Mamasapano operation.

Rappler - Why Roxas, Espina out of loop

By Bea Cupin | Rappler

Logo_RapplerMANILA, Philippines – Former Philippine National Police (PNP) chief Director General Alan Purisima on Tuesday, February 10, said he had “advised” a police general to keep the PNP Officer-in-Charge and the Interior Secretary out of the loop in a high-level operation to maintain “operational security.”

Purisima, who resigned last week as PNP chief, is under fire for his apparent role in “Oplan Exodus,” a January 25 operation to neutralize bomb-makers Zulkifli bin Hir, better known as “Marwan,” and Abdul Basit Usman.

The elite PNP Special Action Force (SAF) was able to kill Marwan but lost 44 of its elite troopers in a bungled extraction operation. While Purisima was kept in the loop, PNP OIC Deputy Director General Leonardo Espina and Interior Secretary Manuel Roxas II weren’t.

The following is the exchange between Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr and Purisima on the latter’s rationale for keeping the two officials out of the loop in the important mission, on the second day of the Senate hearing on the Mamasapano clash.

Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr: I would like to know the reason. Why did you feel there was a need to cut out General Espina from the chain of command?

Purisima: Your honor, the operation said it should be time on target for everybody so I just followed the principle.

Marcos: But this is the acting chief of the PNP. It is not only a usurpation of authority, it’s also breaking the chain of command! And you, as a suspended PNP chief, were issuing orders to keep the acting chief PNP in the dark on a very critical mission. Why did you feel that was necessary?

Purisima: I did not give any orders; I gave advice.

Purisima, a close friend of President Benigno Aquino III, provided the “intelligence packet” for what would eventually be “Oplan Exodus.” Despite his suspension, however, Purisima still sat in meetings with the SAF leadership and even the President himself.

One of those meetings happened in Bahay Pangarap, the official residence of the President in Malacañang.

“Huwag mo munang sabihan ‘yung dalawa, saka na ‘pag nandoon na. Ako na bahala kay General Catapang Don’t inform the two yet, just tell them when the troops are in the area. I’ll tell General Catapang myself),” relieved SAF commander Police Director Getulio Napeñas had quoted Purisima as saying, on the first day of the Senate probe.

On Tuesday, Purisima stuck to his guns, insisting he was only following the SAF’s plan, which was crafted based on intelligence gathered by the PNP.

Marcos would not take Purisima’s explanations sitting down.

Marcos: Nevertheless, that “advice” – which we’ll use for the sake of consistency – that “advice” was nevertheless followed as an order because the fact of the matter is that General Espina was kept out of the loop. Also, the Secretary of the DILG was kept out of the loop? Why did you feel the need to give that advice?

Purisima: For operational security.

Marcos: You do not trust the secretary of the DILG; you do not trust your own second in command with this information?

Purisima: Hindi po ganoon. Ang nakasaad sa plano ng PNP SAF ay time on target. (It’s not like that. What is stated in the PNP SAF plan is time on target.)

When it was Senate President Franklin Drilon’s turn to ask Purisima questions, he again pounded on the reasons behind Purisima’s “advice.” The PNP chief insisted he was only following the SAF’s plans.

“I give up,” an exasperated Drilon told Purisima.

Purisima, however, clarified that although he gave his “advice” following a briefing with the President, Aquino was not privy to this.

Napeñas confirmed the same, but added he took the lack of opposition as the President’s “implied approval” of the mission.

Back to Blog