People's Journal – Marcos bucks Comelec on VCMs

26 October 2016

By Marlon Purificacion | People's Journalfeatured-image-journal-online

THE camp of former Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” R. Marcos Jr. is standing its ground against the decision of the Commission on Elections to release Vote Counting Machines (VCMs) to Smartmatic maintaining that the Comelec’s move must be with the approval of the Supreme Court, sitting as the Presidential Electoral Tribunal (PET).

In a letter sent to Comelec Executive Director Jose Tolentino, Marcos counsel Jose Amor Amorado reiterated their stand that any decision of the poll body in the disposition of election materials used in the May elections should have the approval of the PET as it has sole and exclusive jurisdiction over the election protest of the former senator.

The Comelec had earlier decided to grant the request of Smartmatic to recall 1,365 VCMs which it unilaterally declared to have neither been deployed and/or unused in the May elections.

Amorado told Tolentino that they have already filed their Urgent Manifestation and Motion to the PET seeking to stop the release of the VCMs for being a violation of the Precautionary Protective Order issued by the Tribunal.

They have also asked the PET to oversee the technical evaluation to determine whether or not the machines had been unused.

It is for this reason, according to Amorado, that they have decided not to take part in the scheduled examination of the VCMs yesterday.

“Hence, unless and until, the PET approves the release of the subject VCMs, protestant Marcos will not be sending any representative or any supervisor/lawyer to the 26 October 2016 meeting at Sta. Rosa City to witness your proposed release of the 1,356 VCMs to Smartmatic-TIM,” Amorado said.

The parties in the vice presidential and senatorial electoral protests were scheduled to examine the VCMs Wednesday at the COMELEC Warehouse in Sta. Rosa, Laguna to determine if they were indeed not used in the last elections as a prelude to their release.

Amorado also protested how the examination has turned out to be not an inspection of the VCMs but a “stripping activity” as declared by Tolentino in his letter addressed to the parties. He said they never agreed to any stripping activity.

“Please be informed that during the 19 October 2016 briefing at the Comelec’s Training Room in Sta. Rosa, Laguna, protestant Marcos’ representatives did not agree to any ‘stripping’ activity. To clarify, what was discussed in the said briefing was only the plan of Conelec to release the 1,356 units of contingency machines to Smartmatic-TIM,” he stressed.

Amorado was referring to the 21 October 2016 letter of Tolentino addressed to Marcos’ lawyers asking them for the names of those who will attend today’s “stripping activity” at the Sta. Rosa warehouse.

This is not the first time the Comelec has initiated a stripping activity.

Last August, Marcos’ lawyers asked the Comelec to explain why it approved the stripping of data contained in the SD cards and CCS laptop units used during the last elections. The poll body issued the assailed Order on July 12, 2016 — on the very same day that the PET resolved to issue a protection order to preserve the integrity of all election paraphernalia used in the May elections.